
In January 2026, the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office sustained an opposition and refused registration of GOLD PALM for wine, finding it likely to be confused with the registered mark SILVER PALM. (Jackson Family Farms, LLC v. Fairweather, Opposition No. 91291000 (TTAB Jan. 30, 2026) (nonprecedential).) The lesson for any business is simple: your brand doesn't have to be identical to another's to be too close under trademark law.
The dispute itself was straightforward. The applicant applied to register GOLD PALM for wine and other wine-based beverages. Jackson Family Farms already held two federal registrations for SILVER PALM, one for wine and one for alcoholic beverages except beers, and opposed on the ground that the GOLD PALM mark was likely to be confused with its own. Because those registrations were in the record and unchallenged, the case turned on a single question: likelihood of confusion.
One of the principal factors in determining likelihood of confusion is the similarity of the marks. Yes, "gold" and "silver" look and sound different, but both marks shared the identical term PALM. Here is the twist that trips up a lot of brand owners: the difference in metals did not save the junior mark. If anything, it hurt. Gold and silver are classic tiers of quality, from Olympic medals to wine-competition awards, and the Board credited evidence that wine buyers understand them that way. A shopper who already knows SILVER PALM could easily read GOLD PALM as the same winery's higher-end line.
While the applicant argued that PALM is weak in the wine world and that a color-plus-object naming convention lets consumers tell such brands apart, the Board was not persuaded. The Board called the record of other uses of “PALM” a far cry from the evidence that has shown a term to be weak in other cases. With the goods identical and the marks confusingly similar, the opposition was sustained.
There are lessons here for anyone who owns a brand or is about to choose one. The best time to catch a conflict is before launch, through a full availability search, long before labels are printed and distributors are lined up. Swapping one color or adjective for another may not be a safe harbor when the shared word is identical.
A trademark is a valuable business asset at every stage: when you launch, a clearance search can spare you a costly rebrand; when you extend a line, it can tell you whether a new name is really distinct; and when you are established, registration and enforcement give you the right to keep a look-alike off the register.
For help clearing, registering, or enforcing a trademark, or navigating an opposition or cancellation before the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, reach out to Joy Durand and DP&F’s Intellectual Property team.
Disclaimer: DP&F represented Jackson Family Farms in this opposition. Every matter turns on its own facts, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Joy Durand is an Intellectual Property attorney whose practice focuses on developing and managing U.S. and international trademark portfolios, including trademark clearance, prosecution of applications before the United States Patent and Trademark Office, and enforcement. She represents clients in federal court and before the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, where she has obtained favorable judgments in opposition and cancellation proceedings for clients across numerous industries, including alcoholic beverages, food, consumer products, construction, and technology (including software and AI).
Joy earned her J.D. from the University of San Francisco School of Law, where she served as Managing Director of the Moot Court Board and received CALI Awards for Excellence in Alternative Dispute Resolution and Civil Procedure II. Joy earned her B.S. from Saint Mary's College of California, and she also has an M.B.A. from Sonoma State University.

POSTED BY Alexis C. Bricker
If you own a business in California, a recent change to how the Secretary of State handles business filings may materially affect your ability to meet statutory deadlines.
Here’s What Changed
Effective August 1, 2026, the California Secretary of State (“SOS”) changed its business filings process to become more secure. Previously, business filings could be completed online through any bizfile account, and certain filings were approved automatically.
Now, anyone filing on behalf of a business must first obtain “Full User Access” to that specific business entity. If you have a business entity registered in California, then this update applies to you and will likely create delays in your filing process.
Check Before You Toss
If you receive any correspondence from the California Secretary of State, do not discard it because it could contain important information pertaining to your business. Notifications from the Secretary of State can come in the form of an email from “no-reply@sos.ca.gov” or by mail from the address below:
Filing Deadlines Won’t Wait
Obtaining Full User Access can be a lengthy, complication-prone process that should not be left to the last minute. California business entities typically have either annual or biennial filing deadlines that must be met. Any delay in obtaining access puts good standing with the state at risk.
Getting Full User Access
There are two primary methods of obtaining Full User Access. The applicable method depends on how the entity is currently configured in the SOS system. Each method carries risks that can delay or prevent timely access.
Method 1: No bizfile Account on File
The filer must request a PIN from the SOS. The filer should log into their bizfile account, search for their business, then click “Request PIN”. The PIN is then mailed to the business entity's address of record.
Associated risks:
Misidentification as a scam. Individuals receiving mail at the business entity's address of record frequently assume that the letter containing the PIN is fraudulent and discard it.
Lost or unfulfilled requests. The SOS has been failing to process some PIN requests. As a result, clients may wait weeks for a PIN letter that never arrives.
Method 2: bizfile Account Already on File
The filer must request access from the individual who manages the existing account. The filer should log into their bizfile account, search for their business then click “Request Access”. This will send a request via email to the individual who manages the account.
Associated risks:
Unknown account manager. Many individuals do not know who manages their business entity's account. The account holder is often someone who filed a business filing online within the preceding two years, but this is not always the case.
Request misidentified as spam. The access request is delivered by email from a sender that may appear to be spam and is therefore frequently deleted or ignored.
No second attempt. Only one access request may be made per bizfile account. If the request is ignored, it cannot be resubmitted.
Limited recourse. You may call the SOS main line and submit a request with its special team to identify who maintains the account holding access. However, the SOS cannot compel an access request to go through (at this time).
Don’t Put All Your Access in One Inbox
When creating a new bizfile account, use a shared group email address (for example, “compliance@business.com”) rather than an individual employee's email address. Doing so avoids concentrating entity access with a single employee and ensures that pertinent notices from the SOS reach multiple individuals.
Helpful Resources
The CA Secretary of State has a step-by-step guide on how to create a bizfile account and request Full User Access: bizfile-online-account-setup.pdf
They also offer a short video on requesting Full User Access: https://youtu.be/WHTdwXI09EU
Need More Help?
If you remain unable to access your business entity, you can contact the Secretary of State by phone at (916) 653-6814 or by email at bizfile@sos.ca.gov. They may be able to give you additional information regarding your business entity.

Join DP&F's Employment Law team for a 2027 Employment Law Update. DP&F partner Jennifer E. Douglas, and employment law attorneys Angela A. Nelson and Marissa E. Buck, will review changes to California employment law taking effect in 2027 and their implications for California employers.
There are two dates to choose from, one on Tuesday, December 8, 2026, and one on Wednesday, January 13, 2027, both beginning at 10:00 a.m. PT. The topics covered will be the same for both sessions, and will include all the new laws employers need to be aware of and the potential changes that should be made to employee handbooks. We will also discuss the ever-expanding use of AI in employment settings.
MCLE Credit - 1hr
SHRM & HRCI - Credit Pending
Webinar Registration
December 8, 2026 | January 13, 2027

AI chatbots (like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude) offer new opportunities for businesses to analyze and synthesize information in support of informed decision-making. But this apparent efficiency comes with legal risks, the primary being the release of confidential or proprietary information.
Covenants to protect confidential information are found in many agreements, often in the so-called “boilerplate” provisions, although these obligations should not be considered afterthoughts. Confidentiality covenants are usually more robust and central to the consideration for entering into contract in the context of Confidentiality Agreements or Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs). Entering into an NDA is often the first step taken when parties are considering a transaction or contractual relationship that will rely on one or both parties sharing protected or sensitive information, the broad release of which would risk a business’s competitive advantage. The promise made to protect confidential information is the consideration offered in exchange for access to new business opportunities.
While there may be some nuance based on AI tools’ terms and conditions of use and the specific language of the NDA, you should assume that feeding confidential information obtained under the protection of an NDA into an AI chatbot will be a breach of the NDA.
NDAs and Third-Party Disclosure
NDAs are built around the core obligation that the recipient of confidential information must safeguard that information and not disclose it to unauthorized third parties. The definition of “disclosure” in most well-drafted NDAs is deliberately broad.
When a user inputs confidential material into an AI chatbot, that information is transmitted to and processed by the platform’s servers. In most cases, the AI provider would qualify as a third party for NDA purposes unless the NDA expressly carves out AI tools or the platform operates under a separate confidentiality arrangement that would satisfy the duties of the receiving party under the NDA terms. Many standard NDAs predate generative AI entirely so do not include an express prohibition of AI use, but silence on the issue does not signal permission.
The Data Retention Problem
The risk of an NDA breach is compounded by what happens to data after it is uploaded to an AI chatbot. Many AI platforms retain user inputs and may use them to train their models. Even where providers offer opt-out mechanisms, default settings on consumer-facing tools frequently involve data retention or review, meaning confidential information may persist in a third-party environment indefinitely. Once stored, that information may be subject to further use, including being sold, shared, or disclosed to third parties in future outputs.
Enterprise or closed-model AI platforms may offer stronger protections and therefore not constitute disclosure, but this assumption should not be assumed.
Practical Recommendations
The use of NDAs serves, first and foremost, as a deterrent. By clearly defining what information is confidential and how it may be used or disclosed, the NDA removes ambiguity and puts every recipient on notice of exactly what is expected to ensure performance.
Organizations should not wait for litigation to crystallize the risk. If you or your company is party to any NDAs (you probably are), four steps are advisable to take now: (1) audit existing NDAs for language that may capture AI platform disclosure; (2) update standard templates to expressly address AI tool usage; (3) implement internal policies that distinguish between consumer and enterprise AI deployments; and (4) review AI provider terms of service, data retention policies, and available confidentiality provisions before using any platform with sensitive data.
The convenience of AI tools should not come at the cost of confidentiality obligations. Businesses handling sensitive commercial information, operating under multiple NDAs, or relying on trade secret protection should treat AI usage as a live compliance issue, not a future one.
For assistance with managing confidentiality obligations in the evolving AI landscape, contact Carol Kingery Ritter and DP&F’s Business Law group.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Carol Kingery Ritter is Co-Managing Partner of DP&F and leads the firm’s business law and real property practice groups. Her practice includes general corporate formation, compliance, and restructuring and business contracts, with specific expertise in essential wine business contracts, such as grape purchase agreements, distribution agreements, wine production agreements, vineyard leases and vineyard redevelopment agreements, and counseling clients through complex vineyard, winery and wine business sales and acquisitions.
Carol received her J.D. from the University of California, Berkeley School of Law, having previously earned a B.A. in Anthropology from UC Berkeley, graduating with Highest Honors.

DP&F Alcohol Beverage Law & Compliance attorney Theresa Barton Cray, will speak next month for the San Diego County Bar Association’s 11th Annual Beer, Wine, and Spirits Law MCLE occurring on October 1st, 2026, in San Diego.
FROM THE EVENT ORGANIZERS:
The 11th Annual Beer, Wine, and Spirits Law MCLE is a premier legal education event dedicated to the evolving landscape of alcohol beverage law. This conference brings together industry leaders, attorneys, regulators, and business professionals to discuss key legal and regulatory issues affecting breweries, wineries, and distilleries. Attendees will gain valuable insights into licensing, compliance, distribution, intellectual property, and emerging trends in the industry. Designed for both seasoned practitioners and newcomers, the event offers expert panels, networking opportunities, and CLE credits to keep legal professionals at the forefront of alcohol beverage law.
An optional networking mixer will be held at Ballast Point Little Italy (2215 India St, San Diego, CA 92101) after the MCLE program has finished.

With wine consumption declining nationwide and California’s winemakers feeling the squeeze, Sacramento has delivered a meaningful win for the state’s wine producers. Senate Bill 917 opens the doors of California’s certified farmers’ markets to winemakers, including many small winemakers who have long been shut out – giving them a new avenue to reach consumers directly.
In January 2026, State Senator John Laird introduced Senate Bill 917 to modernize California’s farmers’ market wine regulations. The California Legislature passed the bill in August 2026, and it was approved by Governor Newsom on August 27, 2026.
Codified at Section 23399.4 of the California Business and Professions Code (the “ABC Act”), the prior law permitted Type 02 winegrower licensees to obtain a Type 79 farmer’s market license to sell at certified farmers’ markets only those wines produced from grapes grown by the winegrower itself. In practice, this requirement closed the door on small, boutique wineries that purchased their grapes from other growers.
SB 917 has updated California’s ABC Type 79 certified farmers’ market wine permit to now allow all wineries, including many small wineries that source grapes from third-party growers, to sell wine and conduct instructional tastings at certified farmers’ markets. For these wine producers, this change means a genuine opportunity to sell directly to the public.
And it doesn’t stop at wine sales! Previously, only one Type 79 permit holder could conduct an instructional or educational consumer tasting a particular certified farmers’ market. Now, with the changes enacted under SB 917, that limit has increased and up to three Type 02/79 licensees are permitted to host instructional tastings during a market’s operating hours, subject to the remaining conditions of Section 23399.4.
Effective January 1, 2027, this new law will expand the sale of wine at certified farmers’ markets to new customers, bringing more booths, more pours, and more conversations between the people who make the wine and those who want to enjoy it.
For further questions regarding SB 917, or other alcohol beverage matters, please reach out to Bahaneh Hobel and DP&F’s Alcohol Beverage Law and Compliance team.
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Bahaneh Hobel leads DP&F’s Alcohol Beverage Law and Compliance practice and is a partner in the firm’s Wine Law practice group. She focuses on all aspects of alcohol beverage law and regulation for wineries, breweries, distilled spirits plants, importers, wholesalers and retailers. Bahaneh works extensively with, and represents clients in front of, local, state and federal alcoholic beverage agencies throughout the United States, including the California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control and the Alcohol & Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau.
Bahaneh graduated Phi Beta Kappa and Magna Cum Laude from Emory University in Atlanta, Georgia with a degree in Political Science. She then worked for the United States Solicitor General in Washington D.C. before attending the University of California, Berkeley School of Law, where she served as Projects Editor on the California Law Review. After receiving her law degree, Bahaneh served as a law clerk to the Honorable Richard C. Tallman on the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, and then practiced litigation and transactional law at several established law firms, including O’Melveny & Myers LLP.
Nick Conti earned his J.D. from the Pepperdine University Caruso School of Law. He received his Certificate in Dispute Resolution from Pepperdine’s Straus Institute, adopting a solution-oriented, creative approach to conflict resolution in litigation matters. Nick earned his B.A. in Political Science from Villanova University.
Prior to joining DP&F, Nick worked in the field of special education law, representing students with disabilities in advocating for appropriate educational accommodations and services.

On August 11, 2026, the U.S. Department of the Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (“FinCEN”) announced a final rule that permanently ends beneficial ownership reporting for U.S. companies and U.S. persons under the Corporate Transparency Act. The rule took effect on August 14, 2026. If your company was formed in the United States, you no longer have to file a beneficial ownership report with FinCEN, and you do not have to update or correct one you already filed. For further detail, FinCEN has posted a set of frequently asked questions.
Background
Congress enacted the Corporate Transparency Act on January 1, 2021, as part of the Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2020. FinCEN, a Treasury bureau, then wrote the rules. It issued the original Reporting Rule on September 30, 2022, effective January 1, 2024. However, litigation disrupted the rollout; the Corporate Transparency Act’s reporting requirement was challenged in several federal courts, including the Eastern District of Texas in Texas Top Cop Shop, Inc. v. Garland, 758 F. Supp. 3d 607 (E.D. Tex. 2024), and Smith v. United States Dep’t of the Treasury, 761 F. Supp. 3d 952 (E.D. Tex. 2025), the Northern District of Alabama in Nat’l Small Bus. United v. Yellen, 721 F. Supp. 3d 1260 (N.D. Ala. 2024), and the Western District of Michigan in Small Bus. Ass’n of Mich. v. Yellen, 769 F. Supp. 3d 722 (W.D. Mich. 2025).
Plaintiffs sued on various grounds, including that the Act exceeds Congress’s enumerated powers under the Commerce Clause and that its compelled disclosure of beneficial ownership data is an unreasonable search under the Fourth Amendment. The courts divided, with the Eleventh Circuit upholding the Act against both challenges in an appeal of the Alabama case noted above (Nat’l Small Bus. United v. U.S. Dep’t of the Treasury, 161 F.4th 1323 (11th Cir. 2025)), even as other courts enjoined it, and the Supreme Court stayed one nationwide injunction pending appeal (McHenry v. Texas Top Cop Shop, Inc., 145 S. Ct. 1 (2025)).
In response to the litigation, FinCEN published an interim final rule on March 26, 2025 that narrowed reporting to foreign companies. The August 2026 final rule makes that rollback permanent and adds further relief.
What the Rule Does
The rule permanently removes the requirement for U.S. companies and U.S. persons to report beneficial ownership information to FinCEN. It also exempts foreign companies from reporting U.S. person company applicants, meaning the individuals who helped register the foreign company in the United States, and relieves U.S. persons who hold FinCEN identifiers from any obligation to update or correct the information they already provided. FinCEN has confirmed it will go a step further by deleting information it already holds about individuals it reasonably believes are U.S. persons, such as records tied to a U.S. passport or driver’s license.
Treasury frames the rule as relief for small business owners, which is largely accurate; many larger and heavily regulated entities, such as public companies, banks, insurance companies, and firms with more than 20 full-time U.S. employees and over $5 million in annual gross receipts, were already exempt because they leave a substantial regulatory and financial footprint that makes a separate FinCEN filing unnecessary. The reporting obligation therefore applied mainly to smaller private companies, although the new exemption now effectively removes it for all domestic reporting companies regardless of size.
Who Still Reports, and Where Else This Shows Up
Only foreign entities registered to do business in the United States remain reporting companies, and even they do not report their U.S.-person owners. In other words, if a foreign company that registered to do business here is partly owned or controlled by an American, that American’s identifying details are omitted from the filing.
No other federal agency picks up a general beneficial ownership filing for private domestic companies. Banks must still collect owner information when a company opens an account, but that duty falls on the bank, not the company. Federal securities law still requires large stakeholders in public companies to report to the SEC on Schedules 13D and 13G and Forms 3, 4, and 5, but only for registered, public-company securities.
Elena Moreno is an attorney in DP&F’s Business group. Reach out to Elena.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Elena Moreno assists clients across a broad range of corporate governance and transactional matters. Prior to joining DP&F, Elena practiced in the corporate group of a national law firm servicing the technology and life sciences industries, based out of their Silicon Valley and San Francisco offices. She also served as in-house counsel for a publicly traded technology company.
Elena earned her J.D. from the University of Chicago Law School, where she received an Excellence in Pro Bono Service Award from the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois for her work with the Civil Rights and Police Accountability Clinic. She holds a Bachelor of Arts in Government and Spanish from Cornell University, graduating magna cum laude.

For influencers, digital creators, and creative marketing agencies, generative artificial intelligence (AI) has become an essential brainstorming partner. Whether you are using ChatGPT to structure video scripts, Claude to refine marketing strategies, or Gemini to map out a multi-platform social media campaign, these tools provide an extraordinary boost to daily productivity.
However, the way you interact with these platforms matters enormously when it comes to protecting your intellectual property (IP).
Every time a creator inputs a detailed prompt into an AI model, they are sending data across an external network. If a prompt includes a unique, unreleased brand concept, proprietary campaign taglines, or copyrighted visual references, that creative asset could be exposed depending on the platform's terms of service. Without realizing it, creative professionals may be compromising the exclusivity, confidentiality, and legal protectability of some of their most valuable ideas.
The Real-World Risk: Incidents That Prove the Point
If you think data exposure is a purely theoretical problem, documented incidents prove otherwise.
The Samsung Precedent: Samsung's device solutions division officially permitted employees to use ChatGPT on March 11, 2023. Within approximately twenty days, engineers in its semiconductor division exposed confidential information in three separate incidents. In the first, an engineer pasted proprietary source code to fix a bug. In the second, an engineer pasted code to optimize a test sequence for identifying yield and defective chips. In the third, an employee recorded a confidential internal meeting, transcribed it using a speech-to-text application, and fed the transcript to ChatGPT to generate meeting notes. Samsung's response was to ban generative AI tools across company devices and networks on May 1, 2023, and to develop its own internal AI system — later released as Samsung Gauss — with proper data controls.
The CISA Incident (Reported January 27, 2026): In a high-profile investigation reported by Politico on January 27, 2026, Madhu Gottumukkala, the acting director of the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), uploaded at least four government contracting documents marked “for official use only”—sensitive but not classified—to the public version of ChatGPT between mid-July and early August 2025. The uploads triggered multiple automated security alerts, prompting a Department of Homeland Security review. Gottumukkala had requested and been granted a temporary exception to use the tool by CISA's Office of the Chief Information Officer as part of an initiative to explore AI tools, at a time when most DHS employees were blocked from accessing it due to data retention concerns. The incident demonstrates that even authorized, senior officials can expose sensitive data through consumer AI tools.
For creators, pasting a client's unreleased pitch deck, a confidential campaign calendar, or a unique brand strategy carries the same fundamental risk of unpermitted data exposure.
The Legal Catch: “Reasonable Measures” of Secrecy
Under the Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA), 18 U.S.C. § 1839(3), an idea or strategy only enjoys legal protection as a trade secret if the owner takes “reasonable measures” to keep it secret.
Two recent federal court decisions have begun to test this principle in the AI context. In Trinidad v. OpenAI, Inc., No. 4:25-cv-06328-JST (N.D. Cal. Jan. 5, 2026), Judge Tigar dismissed the plaintiff's trade secret claims under the DTSA because she had voluntarily disclosed her allegedly proprietary frameworks to OpenAI while using ChatGPT to develop them—with no confidentiality protections in place. The court applied the longstanding principle from Ruckelshaus v. Monsanto Co., 467 U.S. 986, 1002 (1984), that voluntarily disclosing a trade secret to a party under no obligation to protect it extinguishes the property right. Two caveats are worth noting: the plaintiff appeared pro se, and the court observed that her complaint suffered from multiple other defects, so the decision's precedential weight is limited. Still, the reasoning on disclosure is straightforward and likely to be cited again.
Separately, in United States v. Heppner, No. 25-cr-00503-JSR (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 17, 2026), Judge Rakoff ruled from the bench on February 10, 2026—with a written opinion following on February 17—that documents a criminal defendant generated using a consumer version of Anthropic's Claude were not protected by attorney-client privilege or the work product doctrine. The court's reasoning rested on several independent grounds: most fundamentally, Claude is not an attorney, and the court noted that recognized privileges require a trusting relationship with a licensed professional who owes fiduciary duties; further, by inputting confidential case material into the tool, the defendant effectively disclosed it to a third party before those materials ever reached his lawyers, and non-privileged materials do not become privileged merely by being shared with counsel afterward; finally, the defendant had not prepared the materials at counsel's direction—he acted of his own volition, so the work product doctrine did not apply. The decision has drawn academic criticism for potentially sweeping too broadly, and the court itself suggested the analysis could differ had counsel directed the use of the tool. Although Heppner arose in a criminal privilege context rather than trade secret law, the underlying principle is directly relevant to creators: disclosing confidential material to a platform that is under no obligation to keep it secret is difficult to characterize as a “reasonable measure” to protect it.
How the Big Three Handle Your Data
The consumer privacy landscape has shifted significantly since the introduction of AI chatbots. ChatGPT and Gemini have long defaulted to using conversational data from free and standard consumer tiers to train and refine their models. Anthropic had previously stood apart by not using consumer data for training by default, but on August 28, 2025, it announced updates to its consumer terms requiring Free, Pro, and Max plan users to make an affirmative data-sharing election. The updated Privacy Policy took effect September 28, 2025, and existing users had until October 8, 2025 to accept the new terms and make their selection in order to continue using Claude. For users who allow their data to be used for training, Anthropic extended data retention from thirty days to five years. Regardless of provider, if you have not actively reviewed and adjusted your privacy settings, your inputs may be in play.
To keep your assets secure, your agency or creator brand should consider employing active prompt engineering guardrails, including the following:
Toggle Off Model Training. Do not rely on default settings. In ChatGPT, navigate to Data Controls and turn off “Improve the model for everyone.” In Claude, review your model training setting in Privacy Settings. For Gemini, disable your “Gemini Apps Activity.” Note that enterprise and API-tier accounts for all three platforms operate under separate contractual data protections—consumer-tier defaults do not apply.
Keep Prompts Abstract. Use conceptual framing instead of literal, proprietary text. Instead of pasting a client's actual, unreleased slogan into your prompt, ask: “Give me five variations of a punchy, five-word slogan for a luxury eco-friendly footwear brand targeting Gen Z.”
Upgrade to Enterprise-Grade Infrastructure. If you or your agency regularly handles sensitive client data, consumer-tier accounts are a legal liability. Enterprise subscriptions and API-tier access contractually isolate your input data from public training pools—a meaningful legal distinction if your trade secret protection is ever challenged.
Generative AI is a great tool for scaling creative output, but its use should not come at the cost of legal protections. By practicing safe prompt engineering, you can harness the power of these tools without inadvertently risking the intellectual property that is core to your business.
Allison N. Berk is an attorney in DP&F’s Intellectual Property group who helps creators scale their business while protecting their brands, campaigns, and ideas. Questions? Reach out to Allison.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Intellectual Property attorney Allison N. Berk focuses on the prosecution and enforcement of client trademark rights, including trademark clearance, prosecution of applications for registration before the United States Patent and Trademark Office, and enforcement. Allison has litigation experience representing clients in federal court and before the Trademark Trial and Appeals Board. Allison also advises student-athletes and influencers on Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) and rights of publicity matters. She provides strategic counsel on brand-identity protection and contract negotiations, ensuring her clients maintain commercial control over their intellectual property. Drawing on her background in trademark enforcement, Allison helps athletes and creators navigate evolving compliance standards while securing the long-term value of their personal brands.
Allison earned her J.D. from the University of California, Berkeley, School of Law, her B.A. in International Relations and African/African American Studies from the University of California, Davis. She is Chair of the Sonoma County Bar Association’s Intellectual Property and Business Law Section and is also a member of the Executive Committee of the Intellectual Property Law Section of the Bar Association of San Francisco.

The California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control issued an Industry Advisory (Tied House Advertising Exceptions Remain Subject to Specific Statutory Conditions) reminding licensees of tied-house laws that generally prohibit suppliers from giving things of value to retailers. The advisory reminds industry members that activities such as joint advertising between a supplier and a retailer where it is not expressly permitted by an exception in the ABC Act, or “pay to play” (whether directly or indirectly), have always been and continue to constitute violations of the tied-house laws. While it is unclear whether a specific event prompted the Department to issue the new advisory, the following passage suggests that partnerships or sponsorships related to the World Cup (and other future big events such as the 2028 LA Olympics) may have something to do with it:
Business and Professions Code sections 25500 and 25502 … prohibit suppliers from furnishing, giving, or lending money to a retailer. These prohibitions extend to retailers holding permanent licenses as well as temporary licenses or permits, such as for festivals or special events like FIFA World Cup or the Olympics, even if the venues they occur in have some sort of exception. Requiring sponsorship or some joint advertising at an event to have product sold there is a violation of the ABC Act.
While there are a number of ways that special events and festivals can be conducted that allow for industry member sponsorship, and in some cases even joint advertising between suppliers and retailers, the tied-house restrictions prohibiting “pay to play” still apply.
Please contact Bahaneh Hobel (bhobel@dpf-law.com) or John Trinidad (jtrinidad@dpf-law.com) if you are considering sponsorships or promotional relationships to ensure that both your participation and marketing are compliant.

In our blog post on the issue of enforceability of the producer’s lien in bankruptcy , we noted the current difficult and uncertain wine market environment. Since that post, the market has not changed much. Given the risk that a lawsuit against a winery on the brink of insolvency may push it into bankruptcy, and the uncertain treatment of the producer’s lien in a winery bankruptcy, we’ve been asked by grape growers about alternative methods of attempting to collect payment from a delinquent winery. This post discusses the use of the California Department of Food and Agriculture (“CDFA”) complaint process as one such potential alternative. As explained below, although this process is an administrative procedure in the nature of alternative dispute resolution, rather than a lawsuit, it is likely to be taken seriously by respondent winery.
Basic Background
Processors of agricultural products, including processors that handle and process wine grapes (i.e., wineries), are required to be licensed by the CDFA. Cal. Food & Agric. Code §§ 55521, et seq. Such licensure is in addition to any other licenses that may be required, for example, a winegrower license issued by the California Alcoholic Beverage Commission, or a winery permit issued by the federal Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau. Thus, if a winery engages in a violation of the so-called Processors Law, Cal. Food & Agric. Code §§ 55601, et seq. , it may be subject to investigation, censure and punishment by the CDFA.
There’s an app – or at least a government agency – for that
The Processors Law governs wineries and other entities that buy and process agricultural products, including grapes. Under the California Food and Agricultural Code, the failure to pay a grape grower is primarily regulated under the Processors Law. This legal remedy is separate and apart from a breach of contract remedy under the contract (grape purchase agreement) and common law.
The CDFA has a branch – aptly called the Market Enforcement Branch (“MEB”) – dedicated to enforcement of the Processors Law, so as to ensure confidence and stability in the agricultural marketplace and to protect against unfair business practices between producers, handlers, and processors of California farm products.[1]
Among other things, the MEB processes complaints filed by agricultural product producers.[2] Violations of the Processors Law that are relevant to grape growers may include, for example: failure to pay in full, Cal. Food & Agric. Code § 55872; failure or refusal to make timely payment as specified in the contract, Cal. Food & Agric. Code § 55878; and failure or refusal to render a true and correct account of sales or to pay for farm products received on consignment, Cal. Food & Agric. Code § 55879.
Among other remedies, the processor/winery risks revocation of its processor’s license (which is required for a winery to operate), see , e.g. , Bronco Wine Co. v. Frank A. Logoluso Farms (1989) 214 Cal.App .3d 699, 705, as well as imposition of late charges and administrative fines. Accordingly, wineries tend to take MEB investigations very seriously.
So how do I complain?
To file a complaint for failure to pay, grape growers must submit a Verified Complaint [3] to the MEB along with the relevant filing fee (the amount of the fee is based on the value of the debt). Note that any verified complaint must be filed not later than nine months from the date a complete account of sales was due.[4] Cal. Food & Agric. Code § 55745. Make sure to include copies of all contracts, invoices, bills of lading, and relevant correspondence, all in duplicate. Instructions and additional information about the complaint process are available on the MEB website, https://www.cdfa.ca.gov/mkt/meb/complaint_process.html .[5]
The Verified Complaint will be served on the respondent winery within five days of the date on which a signed verified complaint, the filing fee, and the denial of federal jurisdiction are accepted by the MEB. The respondent winery will then have 30 calendar days to answer and submit its supporting documents. After receipt and review of the answer, the MEB will issue to both parties a written factual summary based on the documentation that has been filed, typically within 90 days of the date of the initial filing of the verified complaint.
During the process, it may be determined that the issues involved in the dispute can be remedied by informal mediation with a neutral and unbiased party. However, if a settlement cannot be reached within 30 calendar days after the MEB summary is issued (approximately 120 days from the date the verified complaint is accepted), and for matters involving a debt of $30,000 or less, either the complainant grape grower or the respondent winery can request expedited arbitration, before an arbitrator from a panel of arbitrators registered with the CDFA, upon payment of a $600 filing fee.[6] See Cal. Code Regs. tit. 3, § 1703.3(a); Cal. Food & Agric. Code § 56382.8(g).
Thus, the entire CDFA complaint procedure is, in essence, an alternative dispute resolution process that occurs outside of the courtroom, but under the auspices of a state agency with disciplinary powers. See Bank of Am., N.A v. Cap. Med Farms, LLC (E.D. Cal. May 6, 2025) No. 2:24-CV-02309-DJC-CKD, 2025 WL 1307793, at *1, fn. 3 (“The [California Department of Food & Agriculture] cannot issue judgments but will consider a complaint, a response, and issue factual findings that may lead to further alternative dispute resolution and/or potential disciplinary actions against licensees[.]”) As such, in comparison to litigation, the CDFA procedure is bound to be a less expensive and more streamlined option for grape growers – and possibly also more likely to result in an agreed resolution of the debt.
DP&F Senior Counsel Ory Sandel is a member of DP&F’s Litigation group.
[1] See https://www.cdfa.ca.gov/mkt/meb/
[2] Note that if a complaint involves fruit moving in interstate commerce, it must first be filed with the U.S. Department of Agriculture. In such cases, the MEB requires a letter of denial from the federal agency before the MEB will take any action. See https://www.cdfa.ca.gov/mkt/meb/
[3] “Verified”, in this case, means that the person signing the Complaint certifies that the statement of factual allegations and description of events, as well as and any attachments to the Complaint, are true and correct.
[4] The nine-month period does not include the length of time it takes to secure a written letter of denial from a federal agency. See id. ; see footnote 2, supra .
[5] The following is by way of general summary only, and should not be relied on in any MEB proceeding. Specific regulations applicable to MEB investigations and procedure may be found in Chapter 2.2 of Division 3 in Title 3 of the California Code of Regulations, Cal. Code Regs. tit. 3, §§ 1702 et seq. As with all posts on DP&F’s blog, this post does not constitute legal advice.
[6] See Cal. Code Regs. tit. 3, § 1703.3; see also https://www.cdfa.ca.gov/mkt/meb/Forms/New%20forms/Expediated%20Arbitration%20Pamphlet%20_5-07_.pdf

